After Babel, The Machine?

Translation passes — Effingers, Chapter 25 ("Frühling" / "Spring")

Working log. One entry per revision pass (up to five). Output lives in translation.md.

Pass 1 — 2026-05-25 (first full draft)

Goal of this pass: get the meaning exactly right, end to end, and lock the load-bearing structural decisions — above all the Frühling refrain — while letting the prose breathe in the established English voice (Wharton/Powell/ Mitford register; blended mid-Atlantic midcentury) rather than going stark.

Approach & decisions taken:

  1. The refrain as a reusable template (priority #1). Settled on: "What a spring day, this Saturday in March of the year 1887! What sweetness, at ten in the morning!" — chosen because it is exclamatory, keeps the demonstrative ("this Saturday"), keeps the noun-exclamation ("What sweetness"), and flexes for all seven hours AND for the novel-wide frame (Ch 68 1913, Ch 131 1930, Epilog 1948). I reproduced each of the seven occurrences with its exact mutation:

    • full form at 10 a.m. / 11 a.m. / 1 p.m. / 5 p.m. / 3 a.m.;
    • the 6 p.m. mutation drops "of the year," folds the hour into sentence 1, and swaps the second sentence for a new exclamation ("What a throng in the Chausseestraße!");
    • the 8 p.m. mutation is a single sentence with the hour folded in. Kept "of the year 1887" as the full form precisely so it can drop to "March 1887" at 6 p.m. — preserving Tergit's own variation.

  2. Chapter 25 as overture — seeds planted, not flagged. Translated each of the seven hourly scenes so its long-range payoff is latent, never foreshadowed (Tergit never lets the end seem fated): Eugenie's munificence; Sofie's first love-letter (→ her suicide); Waldemar's "the spirit is in danger… devoured by the state and the machines" (→ his arias and death); Waldemar & Susanna (→ her ruin and suicide); Mayer's house-elegy and the dark leather wall-hangings (→ the Epilog ruins); Amalie the New Woman; Theodor & Wanda (→ the 1933 Nazi smear). The "Annettchen" Easter-egg (Käte Winkel's lost love = Karl & Annette) left buried for the alert reader.

  3. Signatures kept: fronted predicates ("Down the Tiergartenstraße the horses raced"; "Soft was the red carpet, soft the sofa…, soft the chair…" — the triple anaphora intact); flat death/turn sentences ("But he did not come." / "All gone." / "She had worked, too. But this way was easier."); laconic repetition ("such kindness, such kindness"; "don't overdo it… don't overdo it"; "Good, Susanna, good"; "Adieu." "Adieu." "Adieu."); bare "said" tags; the street-montage catalogues kept as inventory ("Railway over the river, a little omnibus with its pony, a one-legged man calling…").

  4. Embedded quotation rendered, not buried: Schumann's A Woman's Love and Life with Sofie's own adapted line ("Since I beheld you… I see you alone" — kept her personalizing misquotation, per the persona note that a half-remembered quotation is part of the truth); Heine's "The lotus flower is afraid…"; Wagner's "Magic Fire"; the Latin "in verba magistri"; the marching tag "fifers and drummers, warlike sound"; the dated prophecy "the 16th of March 1887."

  5. Domestication of society-words (persona defaults): Coupé → "carriage"; Taburett → "stool"; Stadtrat → "the Councilor"; Frühstück at 1 p.m. with lobster → "luncheon" (the elegant register, not "breakfast"). Kept Privatdozent and Junker (load-bearing terms). Kept the financial/material specifics exactly — "two thousand marks," "twenty pfennigs to sew the skirt," "ten marks a week," "ten percent," the Sardinian war loan of '59, "§ 1378" — because the figures are where the morality is.

  6. Berlin kept present (light hand): all street names, pub names ("the Frischer Hammel"), and "the Tiergarten" left in German; Berlinisch rendered as period Anglo slang with light dropped register, NOT Cockney/Brooklyn ("You daft goose, somebody ought to box your ears…"; Wanda's "Nah, don't go killing anybody…"; "The chump!").

  7. Register contrast inside dialogue (ventriloquism): let the old Historian's speeches run in longer learned periods against Waldemar's terser thrusts; Eugenie warm-grand; Mayer the ruined aesthete dry and elegiac; Amalie clipped and sharp; Paul decent and conventional; the Chausseestraße voices broad and warm.

Open questions to weigh in later passes (NOT yet resolved):

Status: Pass 1 complete. Full chapter drafted in translation.md. Not revised. Awaiting the offer of pass 2.

Pass 2 — 2026-05-25 (light naturalness & clarity polish)

Judgment going in: re-read the whole chapter against the German with fresh eyes. The structure, the seven-part hourly architecture, the Frühling refrain and all its mutations, the register map, and the voice are right — I left them untouched. But I caught a handful of spots where idiomatic German had come out as faint translationese or small awkwardness: the kind of friction a self- translating author notices on a second look and would not let into a final text. Fixing them serves the persona's central worry — keep the breezy lift, never let the prose go stiff or stark. Five targeted, light-handed changes; no rewriting, no additions, nothing structural.

Changes & why:

  1. "in undress tunic" → "in undress tunics" (the officers, 10 a.m. scene). Plain grammar: the plural reads naturally for die Offiziere; the singular was a small stumble.

  2. "It's only because we've just the one room. That's the only reason it is." → "…That's the only reason." (the wife in the Chausseestraße.) The trailing "it is" was meant to echo the Berlin inverted tag "Bloß deshalb is det", but in English it reads as an error rather than as dialect. Dropped it; the only…only doubling (the laconic repetition) is preserved without the friction.

  3. "Things discuss themselves more easily when one knows the other in person." → "It's easier to talk things over when one knows the other in person." (Mayer, the insurance agent.) "Es bespricht sich leichter" is wholly idiomatic German — an ordinary impersonal-reflexive, not a stiff construction. Rendering it as "things discuss themselves" imported an awkwardness the original does not have and made Mayer sound odd in a way he isn't. The fix keeps his courteous register while losing the translationese. (Fidelity gain, not a flattening of character.)

  4. "a young girl applied to me, for copying letters" → "a young girl applied to me for letter-copying." (Paul, on women in the office.) Removed the awkward comma and tightened Briefkopieren to a clean compound.

  5. "pasted dark leather hangings" → "pasted up dark leather wall-hangings" (Mayer on the Oppner house, 5 p.m.). "hangings" alone risks reading as drapery; Ledertapeten is a leather wall-covering, so "wall-hangings" is clearer — and it sets up the cross-novel echo with the Epilog, where this same dark leather is seen burned ("Die Ledertapete im alten Speisezimmer war verbrannt"). "pasted up" is the natural verb for wall-covering.

Deliberately NOT changed (considered and kept):

Status: Pass 2 complete. The chapter now reads, to my ear, without friction; the lift is intact and the few stiff joints are gone. I consider it essentially final — I would not change more without risking the "lightest possible hand." Stopping here to report; will revise further only if you ask.

Pass 3 — 2026-05-25 (review pass — NO changes made)

Decision: final as it stands. translation.md left unchanged.

Re-read the whole chapter slowly against the German once more, hunting for any real mistranslation, missed nuance, or slack in the lift that the first two passes hadn't caught. Found none of the kind pass 2 fixed. The candidates I weighed and deliberately rejected:

Confirmed the load-bearing things are right: the Frühling refrain and its seven mutations chime and advance the hours; the diurnal round closes on "What sweetness, at three in the morning!" with the deadpan sweetness-over-the-abyss the German lands (Theodor's despair and Wanda's arithmetic just behind it); the overture-seeds are planted without foreshadowing; the chapter reads with lift, not starkness.

Further tinkering would be fussing, not improving — it would strain the "lightest possible hand" the voice depends on. Calling it final. (Passes available: stopping at 3 of 5 by choice.)

Back to→ Appendix